Roof Insurance: ACV vs. Replacement Cost

Winston-Salem, NC 8/11/2015

Will your homeowners's insurance policy fully cover the cost of damage to your roof? Many states have been hit hard by wind and hail damage these past few years; as a result, you may now have a gaping hole in your Homeowner's policy related to roof insurance coverage. Many policyholders have indicated that they are not aware of recent changes made by multiple large HO carriers that significantly impact the way that claims are settled for roof damage.

A string of unusually costly years for residential roof damage claims in Oklahoma, Kentucky, Tennessee, North Carolina and elsewhere has prompted some insurers to dial back the roof coverage portion of their home insurance policies, especially on older roofs. One popular trend is to offer "actual cash value," or ACV, coverage on your roof instead of full "replacement cost value," or RCV. What's the difference? With ACV, your insurer pays to repair or replace your roof, less your deductible and depreciation for the age and type of roof. With RCV, however, the insurer pays all costs to make your roof whole again without factoring in depreciation, once you've met your deductible.

Allstate led this belt-tightening trend two years ago, though the company prefers to say that its House & Home policy offers a "scheduled roof depreciation option" for wind and hail damage on older roofs and is not the same as actual cash value coverage. Other insurers in hard-hit states, including Farm Bureau Insurance of Tennessee and American Family Insurance, also have moved away from traditional replacement cost value roof coverage. Michael Barry, spokesman for the Insurance Information Institute, an industry trade group, calls it a logical response, from the insurer's perspective. "If you look at a company like Allstate, they have all these homeowners who have gotten three $20,000 roof replacements in 3-5 years. That's not a sustainable business model when they're charging you $1,100 a year for home insurance," he says. Unfortunately, the trend leaves homeowners who have never heard of ACV or RCV at a loss as to which coverage to choose (if given the choice) - and could stick some who failed to spot a change on their policy renewal notice with a steep roof repair bill down the road.

For example, say your $20,000 roof is 10 years old and your home insurance policy has a $1,000 deductible. If a storm destroys it and you have actual cash value roof coverage that depreciates the roof's value by $1,000 per year, your out-of-pocket share of the cost for a new roof would be $11,000 (comprised of the $1,000 deductible plus $10,000 for the depreciation). With replacement cost coverage, you'd be out only the $1,000 deductible. "The dollar difference between replacement cost value and actual cash value can be huge," Barry admits.

To avoid such surprises, Allstate gives House & Home policyholders a "roof payment schedule" upfront that states exactly what their roof will be worth based on age and roof type, should disaster strike. "It's really a loss settlement schedule," says Allstate Vice President Laurie Pellouchoud. "It is only applied in the event of a wind and hail loss, so for other types of losses such as fire, your roof would be covered for full replacement cost." Pellouchoud declined to estimate what policyholders might save on their premiums by choosing the loss settlement roof insurance option, saying only, "This is a way for customers to choose to purchase less coverage and pay less money." House & Home policies are available in 27 states so far, she adds.

At the trade group meeting of the American Insurance Association, AIA chief claims counsel Jim Whittle sees the actual cash value roof option as a good thing for consumers. We disagree! "A lot of folks like ACV because they realize a significant savings in their premium, and as a result of that they are, in essence, self-insuring a portion of the loss," he says. Even so, Whittle says he recently switched insurers for his Maryland home after he found a policy with replacement cost roof coverage for less than he paid for his previous ACV policy.

Consumer advocates find little to celebrate in the move toward actual cash value roof insurance coverage. Amy Bach, executive director of United Policyholders, a San Francisco-based insurance consumer group, says lower- and middle-income Americans and owners of older homes are being penalized. "You always hear insurers say after every storm, 'This wiped out our entire year of premiums.' Well, do they give people money back on the years that they don't file claims? No," Bach says. "At the end of the day, (ACV) makes people feel like they're being short-changed."

Even Allstate agents are balking at the trend. "In our opinion, the House & Home policy is a major step backward for consumers," Jim Fish, executive director of the National Association of Professional Allstate Agents, said in an email. But Whittle says any perceived unfairness has a time-honored remedy for home insurance customers. "Shop around," he says. "We have 3,000 property and casualty insurers in the United States, so there is a lot of variability in their products and how they market, and that's a good thing. That variability offers a lot of options in the marketplace."

At Wilson Insurance, we guarantee that you will know how your HO policy will respond to a roof damage claim before it happens. None of the carriers with whom we are currently placing business have had to make material changes to the loss settlement provisions regarding the valuation of damage to roofs in their HO contracts. If you have questions about your coverage, or would like us to offer competitive options in response to recent coverage or rate changes made by your current carrier, please contact us today.

Wilson Insurance - Our Knowledge is Your Best Assurance™.

* excerpts from Jay MacDonald article: "Roof Insurance: ACV versus Replacement Cost"

View All News Articles

What Our Customers Say!

Fletcher, I wanted to just send you a note to let you know how thankful we are to Linda Welborn for all of her work on our homeowner's and auto policies. This is the first time I can honestly say that someone took the time to explain the different levels of insurance to me and discuss what we actually needed, rather than what they wanted to sell me. I learned so much from this experience! In addition to the "education" she provided, she provided a proposal to us very quickly and was able to finalize everything in a very timely manner. We are thrilled to be working with your team going forward! Sincerely, Laura Blythe

Laura Blythe

Read what others have to say.

What's New

Wilson Insurance Services Team!

2/22/2018

Our newest team photo!

What You Should Know About Rental Car Insurance

2/1/2018

There are some very serious contractual gaps in coverage for rental vehicles. Even if you purchase their Collision Damage or Physical/ Loss Damage Waivers, many rental car contracts exclude the following:

Theft of the Vehicle
Tolling, or Turning the Vehicle Over
Lease Gap coverage
Loss of Use
Glass, Tire and Undercarriage Damage
Animal Collision
Flood and Hail Damage
Damage above the Windshield
Individuals who rent personal vehicles for extended periods and do not have a Personal Auto policy in force
Drivers who rent, and do not own another vehicle insured elsewhere, need to be expecially careful here

The Five Costliest Traffic Tickets for Auto Insurance

1/15/2018

Those whirling blue lights in the rearview mirror usually mean just one thing: It's traffic ticket time. The worse the violation, the more your car insurance costs may rise because it's more likely you'll be considered a bigger risk to the insurer. Rack up a combination of the nastiest violations plus a few accidents, and insurers may even refuse to cover you, says Loretta Worters, spokeswoman for the Insurance Information Institute, a trade group.

It boils down to matching the premium you pay to your risk as a customer, says State Farm spokesman Dick Luedke. "Sometimes you get lucky and violate (traffic laws) a lot and don't get caught, and sometimes you do it once, and you are caught," he says. "That's why we use all sorts of other things to measure risk as well." So it's tough to say how much your insurance premiums will rise per violation. Different insurers calculate premium costs differently, Worters says. With the help of experts, including J. Robert Hunter, insurance director for the Washington, D.C.-based Consumer Federation of America, we now identify what are considered the five worst traffic violations for your insurance bills: